
Through a Housingwire post by Jon Prior, I’ve learned of a proposal that would allow underwater homeowners who are current on their payments to refinance their mortgages at lower rates. Underwater homeowners are those who owe more on their mortgage than their home is currently worth (this is also known as having negative equity). More than 11 million American homeowners with mortgages are underwater according to a recent Harvard study on the housing market.
One of the problems with being underwater is that it results in the homeowner having a high loan-to-value ratio (LTV). Once an LTV meets a certain threshold, the borrower is precluded from refinancing because lenders typically will not underwrite high LTV loans, as they are more likely to eventually default. As a result, these homeowners are stuck in their homes. Many of these people purchased homes during the peak of the market when rates were significantly higher than they are today, so they are not only unable to sell their homes, but they are missing out on substantial monthly savings.
The bill (the Helping Responsible Homeowners Act of 2011) proposed by Barbara Boxer (D-CA) would allow underwater homeowners whose loans are owned by Fannie Mae or Freddie Mac to refinance at current mortgage rates. According to the Housingwire article, more than 8 million mortgages owned or backed by Fannie or Freddie have interest rates of 6 percent or higher. The bill would allow millions to refinance. Sen. Boxer commented:
“They have been so solid in their mortgage payments every month even though the value of their home is going down. This bill would remove barriers that kept them trapped.”
The bill was referred to the Committee on Banking, Housing, and Urban Affairs back in January. The majority of bills do not make it out of committee, but this one carries the support of many industry groups, as well as some influential Senators and businessmen, such as Bill Gross, founder of bond giant PIMCO. One of the drawbacks of the proposal is that mortgages with LTVs over 125 cannot be securitized, so these mortgages would have to be held in portfolio by Fannie and Freddie.
I have no idea if this bill has a legitimate chance of becoming law. It would be a huge boon to underwater borrowers as well as those in the mortgage industry. I would like to see it pass, although I am not holding out a ton of hope for it.