Today is the day that Facebook will file its initial public offering. There are also rumors that today is the day that President Obama will announce his plan to enable millions of homeowners to refinance at current historically low interest rates. In some ways, it’s as if he is sending a huge “friend request” to American homeowners. Is this good economic policy or simply politics as usual and what effect will it have on mortgage rates?
It appears from early trading in mortgage-backed securities (MBS) today that the markets are focused on the Facebook IPO and stocks are set to rise. This will put pressure on MBS pricing today and could keep rates from falling any further. Unless the stock market surges more than appears likely, mortgage rates will likely remain close to current levels throughout the day.
Several economic reports are also in the mix today. The ADP Employment Change report came in about at the point of expectations though newly created jobs were down significantly from December. Analysts were encouraged however by the surge in new service sector jobs, explaining that a broad-based improvement in employment across all sectors is necessary for sustainable economic growth.
At 10 AM both the Construction Spending report and the ISM Manufacturing Index will be released. The ISM Index is a gauge of manufacturing industry activity and is a very important report. If this report is at or above expected levels, mortgage pricing may feel more upward pressure. If, however, we see a surprise to the downside, then mortgage pricing may improve.
Let’s get back to the President’s refinance plan. According to reports the plan will call for a tax on large banks to pay for the cost of allowing homeowners to refinance into Federal Housing Administration loans. Having failed to get the conservator of the other two government-sponsored housing agencies to go along with a similar plan, the president has turned to the one agency he has direct control over. That being said, the plan has virtually no chance to pass Congress as it has failed to even be acted on twice before.
As to its public policy and economic implications my belief is that it is poor policy to allow refinancing into government (taxpayer) backed mortgages by homeowners that would not otherwise qualify for the loans. Economically, it would provide substantial stimulus initially but it might also have the unintended consequence of causing mortgage rates to rise. Banks unable to handle the onslaught of borrowers, and fearing repurchase risks from loans that go bad, may raise their interest rates to discourage borrowers.






In a departure from traditional behavior, more homeowners continue to pay their credit card bills while falling behind on mortgage payments.
The Bank of Montreal, in a recent report, said the Canadian home values have gone has high as they can. If prices don’t stop increasing, the housing markets could crash in a repeat of the U.S. housing bust.