It’s an interesting question. While I maintain that any housing plan that does not address the problem of negative equity in the housing market ($700b+ worth) is incomplete, HARP and QE3 in conjunction could help a lot of people.
Yesterday Neil Irwin wrote an article for the Washington Post discussing the stimulus options that the Federal Reserve could use in order to stimulate the economy. One interesting possibility is that the Fed could purchase massive amounts of mortgage backed securities (MBS) in order to drive mortgage rates down even further.
The Federal Reserve has a dual mandate, to foster maximum employment and maintain price stability. Right now they are failing miserably at one half of that mandate. Unemployment has been stubbornly high for more than 3 years now. There are many reasons that unemployment hasn’t come down, and only some of the blame can be laid at the feet of the Fed. Nevertheless, two massive rounds of quantitative easing have done little to solve this problem. According to the WAPO article:
“Fed leaders will likely discuss specific options at a policy meeting next Tuesday and Wednesday, though they appear unlikely to take any major actions then. Data in recent weeks have pointed to a slightly improved economy, and many officials are skeptical that any new measures from the Fed to try to lower mortgage or other interest rates would really provide a boost. Three dissented from a related move at a September policy meeting”.
The article indicates that while action is not likely right now, the Fed could soon engage in another round of mortgage-backed securities purchases. Fed Governor Daniel Tarullo commented last week that:









