
Just a quick post here: this morning the S&P/Case Shiller Home Price Index was released for the month of July. The report showed that home prices were stable in July. On average, housing prices are still up year-over-year, with the 20-city composite up 3.2 percent from July 2009.
When looking at this report, it is very important to realize that this is a three month moving average that lags behind two months. As a result, it is pretty far behind what the market is doing right now. When the October and November reports come out, expect to see declines in home values as the effect of government stimulus will largely be absent from those reports.
There are already signs of price erosion in the report:
“With July’s data, 10 of the 20 MSAs are reporting negative annual growth rates. With June’s report only five cities were negative on an annual basis – Atlanta, Cleveland, Dallas, Denver, and Portland all fell back to reporting declining annual growth rates. The three cities in California, Los Angeles, San Diego, and San Francisco, showed the strongest annual growth rates of +7.5%, +9.3%, and 11.2%, respectively; but these too are weaker than June’s print.”
Then we have this quote from David Blitzer, Chairman of the Index Committee at Standard and Poor’s to drive the point home:
“The next few months may give us an idea of the true strength of the housing market, as the temporary economic stimuli will have ended. Housing starts, sales, and inventory data reported for August do not show signs of a robust market, and foreclosures continue.”
Declines in housing prices after the withdrawal of the first time homebuyer tax credit have been predicted for months. It appears we are right on the verge of seeing that happen. If prices start to decline again, it will be very interesting to see what actions, if any, our government takes. If prices begin to fall again, do you think our lawmakers will attempt to intervene? Or will the market be allowed to bottom out? Let me know your take in the comments section below.